Are Electric Cars More Expensive to Insure?

Yes. EVs cost about 42% more to insure than gas cars on average. If you priced EV insurance and the quote surprised you, you are not imagining it. The gap is real and well documented. It is bigger than most other differences between owning an EV and a gas car.

The actual gap

In 2026, EVs cost an average of $3,159 a year to insure with full coverage across all model years. Gas cars cost $2,218. That is a gap of roughly 42%. It is bigger than most people expect. Budget for it before you buy, not after your first renewal notice.

Why it costs more

A few factors add up to that gap.

Repair costs. This is the biggest driver. A minor fender-bender on an EV can cost $5,000 to $10,000 to fix. A comparable gas car costs far less for the same damage. Battery packs, structural parts, and sensor-heavy bumpers all cost more to repair than a plain bumper and radiator.

Specialized parts and labor. EVs have parts that need trained technicians: the battery pack, the electric motor, regenerative braking, and the infotainment system. Fewer shops are certified to do this work. Specialty labor costs more.

Vehicle value. Luxury EVs with proprietary parts and high prices cost much more to insure than mainstream models from brands like Hyundai, Kia, or Toyota. Compare a luxury EV with a mainstream one, and the insurance gap between them is usually wider than the gap between two similar gas cars.

The gap is narrowing for newer models

Here is the good news. The EV premium shrinks to about 18% for model year 2024 or newer. Across all model years combined, it is 42%. Repair shops are learning EV work, and parts are less scarce. Newer models are closing the gap faster than older ones.

Buying a current-year EV instead of an older used one? Expect a premium well below the headline “EVs cost 42% more” number.

What this means for your total cost math

Insurance is easy to underestimate in an EV-vs-gas comparison, especially if you only think about fuel and maintenance. Our EV vs. gas cost calculator has an insurance input. Use your own quotes there. Do not assume the two cars cost the same to insure. The data above shows that is usually wrong.

See our EV ownership cost guide for how insurance fits with the other costs that matter.

Sources

Insurance costs vary a lot by state, driving record, and model. Get a real quote for your situation. Do not budget off these averages.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to insure an electric car?

Usually not. EVs average $3,159 a year to insure versus $2,218 for gas cars in 2026. The gap shrinks to about 18% for model year 2024 or newer.

Why is EV insurance more expensive?

Repair costs are the biggest driver. Battery packs, structural parts, and sensor-heavy bumpers cost more to fix. Specialty labor and higher vehicle values add to the premium.

Do all EVs cost the same to insure?

No. Luxury EVs with high prices and proprietary parts cost much more to insure than mainstream models from brands like Hyundai, Kia, or Toyota.